Sequins in the South

18 Totally Over the Top Freak Shake Recipes

by Leave a Comment

If you like your drinks and desserts totally over the top, you have to save this list of freak shake recipes. Never heard of them before? Let me fill you in. Freak shakes are completely outrageous milkshakes that double as a drink and a dessert. 

You have your milkshake portion (to satisfy your thirst), and loads of confections on top to satisfy any other sweet cravings you might have. From cookies, to cake, to sprinkles, to donuts, and more… there’s nothing too crazy to put on top of a freak shake.

Here are some outrageously delicious ideas to get you started.

a collage of three different freak shakes in glasses

Outrageous Freak Shake Recipes You Just Have to Try

Oreo Freak Shake

Chocolate for days! This extreme Oreo shake is sure to satisfy any chocolate lover’s sweet tooth.

oreo freak shake in a glass topped with oreos, whipped cream and chocolate sauce on a white plate with a wood background

Oreo Freak Shake by Sequins in the South

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Shake

If you’re a newbie to freakshakes, this may be a good one for you to try to get your feet wet. You can’t go wrong with chocolate chip cookies, cookie dough, and chocolate candies.

chocolate chip cookie dough freak shake tipped with cookies and chocolate sauce on a counter with a blue towel in the background

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Freakshake by Emily Enchanted

Vanilla Beet Shake

Vegetables in a freakshake? Oh yes! In this healthier mega milkshake, made with fruit and vegetables, the beetroot gives it a wonderful purple color. It also leaves a subtle flavor that pairs well with the vanilla.

Vanilla Beet Freakshake in two glasses topped with crackers on a wood table

Vanilla Beet Freakshake by Veggie Desserts

Unicorn Shake

Who doesn’t love Unicorns AND milkshakes? We combined the two to create these over-the-top, colorful Unicorn Freakshakes!

unicorn freakshake by Amandas Cookin in a glass topped with donuts and cotton candy with more donuts and marshmallows in the brown background

Unicorn Freakshake by Amanda’s Cookin’

Mermaid Shake

Let your culinary imagination run wild with this over-the-top spectacular Mermaid Freakshake! The flavor is Blue Raspberry, but you can make it vanilla if you prefer and just add food coloring. The donut and yummy candy make this dessert and drink in one a sugary fun fest!

mermaid freakshake by The Soccer Mom Blog in a glass topped with blue and green candy and a blue frosted donut

Mermaid Freakshake by The Soccer Mom Blog

Beauty and the Beast Lemon Shake

Any princess would love this freak shake! The edible pearls and candy flowers really make this shake look as gorgeous as it does delicious. And anything lemon is a winner for me!

beauty and the beast freak shake in a glass topped with a yellow frosted donut and red fondant in the shape of roses on a white background

Beauty and the Beast Freak Shake by See Vanessa Craft

Orange Creamsicle Shake

There’s no better way to celebrate summer than with the classic flavor of an orange creamsicle in the form of a fun milkshake. This is the perfect summer kick-off drink when the kids get out of school.

Orange Creamsicle Milkshake in two glasses topped with whipped cream and vanilla wafer cookies with more cookies, orange slices and straws on the gray counter

Over the Top Orange Creamsicle Milkshake by Food Wine Sunshine

Pumpkin Pie Cinnamon Roll Shake

Pumpkin pie and cinnamon rolls combine to form this deliciously outrageous shake. They’re the perfect fall indulgence.

pumpkin pie freak shake in two glasses topped with half a cinnamon roll on a white table with a sign reading pumpkin spice and everything nice

Mini Pumpkin Pie Cinnamon by Cutefetti

Gingerbread House Milkshake

This Gingerbread House Milkshake recipe is sure to be your new Christmas tradition! It’s a fun holiday freak shake with a candy decorated glass, vanilla ice cream spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and allspice, and topped with delicious cookies.

gingerbread house milkshake in two glasses topped with a gingerbread man and colorful hard candies on a red tray with more candies on the tray

Gingerbread House Milkshake by Home Cooking Memories

Extreme Smoothie

You can indulge without the guilt with this Extreme Smoothie! Customize it anyway you want using your favorite fruits. This will give you a nice big dose of Vitamin C!

freakshake extreme smoothie in a glass topped with fruit slices and skewers with a white brick background

Freakshake Style Extreme Smoothie by Dukes & Duchesses

Elmo Shake

These Elmo freakshakes are perfect for birthday parties or as a “just because” treat!

elmo freakshake in two glasses tipped with whipped cream and sprinkles and an elmo cookie on a brown table

Elmo Freakshakes by Amanda’s Cookin’

S’mores Freakshake

This is a fun twist on a classic recipe. With chocolate dipped graham crackers, marshmallows, and a mini slice of S’mores pie, it’s a decadent treat that you shouldn’t wait until summer for.

smores freak shake in two glasses topped with chocolate dipped graham crackers, marshmallows, and a mini slice of S'mores pie on a blue and white polka dot linen on a brown table

S’mores Freak Shake by Hello Little Home

Sea Salt Caramel Cookie Milkshake

The base of this milkshake is sea salt, caramel, vanilla sandwich cookies and vanilla ice cream, but it goes over the top with homemade caramel corn, nutter butters, Twix, whipped cream, and loads of caramel.

sea salt caramel cookie monster milk shake in a glass topped with homemade caramel corn, nutter butters, Twix, whipped cream, and loads of caramel on a white plate on a wood table

Salted Caramel Cookie Monster Milkshake by Hezzi D’s Books and Cooks

Banana Split Shake

This is a fun, over-the-top way to enjoy a classic dessert like a Banana Split. The star of the show is the banana flavored wafers, but you’ll love the banana, cherries, chocolate syrup and sprinkles that top off this drink.

banana split freakshake in a glass topped with a banana, cherries and banana wafer cookies with more cookies and sprinkles in the background on a wood table

Banana Split Freakshake by This Mama Loves

Cookie Monster Shake

Blue milkshakes+cookie crumbles= Cookie Monster Freakshakes! Great for Sesame Street themed birthday parties

cookie monster freakshake in two glasses topped with a cookie monster cookie

Cookie Monster Freakshakes by Amanda’s Cookin’

Tiramisu Cold Brew Shake

This sweet treat is the perfect summer pick-me-up for the coffee lover and a show stopper if you want a fun dessert for summer entertaining!

tiramisu cold brew freakshake in a glass topped with whipped cream, cookies, and tootsie rolls on a wood background

Tiramisu Cold Brew Freakshake by Dukes & Duchesses

BB-8 Star Wars Freak Shake

This would be such an amazing treat at a Star Wars themed birthday party! The BB-8 cookies are made out of Nutter Butters. Isn’t that clever?

BB-8 Star Wars Freak Shake in a glass topped with oreos, nutter butters, mini powdered donuts, and orange twizzlers on a black table

BB-8 Star Wars Freak Shake by Mom Endeavors

Mardi Gras King Cake Milkshake

This Mardi Gras King Cake Milkshake is crazy big with crazy big flavors. Of course, you wouldn’t expect anything less from a milkshake that has been named after a day like Fat Tuesday.

mardi gras milkshake in a glass topped with whipped cream and mini donuts on a black background

Mardi Gras King Cake Milkshake by This Ole Mom

Save all these crazy freak shake recipes for later by pinning the image below. You’ll want to come back to this list again and again!

a collage of four different freak shakes with title text reading 18 Freak Shake Recipes You Have to See to Believe

 

 

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Footer